No Response to DNSSEC Requests

Curt Sampson cjs at cynic.net
Sun Apr 15 17:38:46 UTC 2007


I'm running BIND 9.3.4.

I have the following questions:

     a) Under what circumstances does BIND not reply to DNSSEC queries?

     b) How do I get some logging to tell me why it's ignoring DNSSEC
     queries? (dnssec debug level 3 is entirely silent when it's doing
     this.)

     c) Why is it that ns1.cynic.net responds (when queried with dig) to
     queries for "cynic.net SOA" with and without "+dnssec", responds to
     queries for "cynic.net MX" without "+dnssec", but is simply silent
     (no response whatsoever, nothing in the logs) when queried for
     "cynic.net MX" with "+dnssec"? (A DNSSEC-validating server--also
     the same version of BIND 9--has the same issue: it can't see the MX
     records.)

I note also that I can get MXs for ironic.cynic.net just fine, but,
e.g., arctic.cynic.net doesn't work. It seems that any set of MX records
that includes cryptic.cynic.net won't be returned for a DNSSEC query.

cjs
-- 
Curt Sampson            <cjs at cynic.net>             +81 90 7737 2974
   The power of accurate observation is commonly called cynicism
   by those who have not got it.    --George Bernard Shaw



More information about the bind-users mailing list