WG: SUBDOMAINS with CNAMES....

[Kevin Darcy]

The errors imply that there are entries *earlier* in the zone file for
abc.personalserviceagentur.dom-a.de and www.lieferantenansiedlung.dom-a.de.


- Kevin
Siwek, Martin (CENTCO) wrote:

> > Hi all,
> >
> > I think, I have an interresting  question on Bind for you. Even it shows a
> > well known error message, the conditions under which they appear are
> > strange.
> >
> > I changed the names of the original domain in dom-a and dom-b, since the
> > owner of the domaindata mostly wants it.
> > Anyway it reflects the problem, which I woul like to see as a bug.
> >
> > Here the lines of the rejected zone file for a domain called dom-a.de:
> >
> > ; hosts and subdomains
> > ;
> > www             IN      CNAME   ns.dom-b.de.
> > ftp             IN      CNAME   ns.dom-b.de.
> > inout           IN      A       111.222.333.444
> >
> > $ORIGIN personalserviceagentur.giz.de.
> > abc             IN      CNAME   inout.dom-a.de.
> >
> > $ORIGIN lieferantenansiedlung.giz.de.
> >  www             IN      CNAME   ns.dom-b.de.
> >
> > As you can see, names are not defined more than once, like you might
> > think, when reading the error messages below.
> > The first cname for www.dom-a.de works, but whatever CNAME I use in a
> > subdomain (ORIGIN...), it doesnt work.
> > The CNAME for abc was included for a test.
> > On Bind 8.1.x, it works fine. But on 8.2.3 I can´t get it running.
> >
> > And here are the error messages:
> >
> > abc.personalserviceagentur.dom-a.de has CNAME and other data (invalid)
> > Feb 26 16:28:59 doi34fw1sun2 named[11340]:
> > db.dom-a.de:47:abc.personalserviceagentur.dom-a.de: CNAME and OTHER data e
> > rror
> > Feb 26 16:28:59 doi34fw1sun2 named[11340]:
> > www.lieferantenansiedlung.dom-a.de has CNAME and other data (invalid)
> > Feb 26 16:28:59 doi34fw1sun2 named[11340]:
> > db.giz.de:53:www.lieferantenansiedlung.dom-a.de: CNAME and OTHER data
> > error
> >
> > Well, does anybody out there see, what my eyes are blind for? I would be
> > very greatfull.
> >
> > Thanks in advance
> >
> > Martin Siwek
> > Consultant
> >
> > Integralis
> > Niederlassung Hannover
> > Calenberger Esplanade 1
> > 30169 Hannover
> > Tel.: +49 (511) 123588 - 0, +49 (53 61) 9 - 4 99 13
> > Fax.: +49 (511) 123588 -11, +49 (53 61) 9 - 7 49 06
> > Mail: martin.siwek at integralis.de, extern.martin.siwek at volkswagen.de
> >
> >
> >49 (53 61) 9 - 4 99 13
> > Fax.: +49 (511) 123588 -11, +49 (53 61) 9 - 7 49 06
> > Mail: martin.siwek at integralis.de, extern.martin.siwek at volkswagen.de
>