HP gethostbyaddr errors
James Hall-Kenney
James.Hall-Kenney at sytec.co.nz
Mon Apr 17 01:22:06 UTC 2000
All,
We have a customer who is having trouble with BIND 8.2.2-P5 on HP-UX 11.
They use router management software (Spectrum on Solaris) that maps the
network topology and uses reverse resolution to determine the device name of
the router. Because they are monitoring multiple interfaces on the router,
the name in the management software will change regularly. To circumvent
this, we have created the reverse resolution entries to all resolve to the
same name ie:
Forward Resolution entries:
interfacea 129600 IN A 10.13.255.5
interfaceb 129600 IN A 10.13.128.1
interfacea 129600 IN A 10.13.130.1
Reverse Resolution entries: (13.10.in-addr.arpa)
5.255 129600 IN PTR interfacea.ssi.govt.nz.
1.128 129600 IN PTR interfacea.ssi.govt.nz.
1.130 129600 IN PTR interfacea.ssi.govt.nz.
They have a different management product - HP Network Node Manager running
on HP-UX 11. For some reason, this host seems to want to verify that the A
record matches the PTR. We get a message in syslog:
gethostbyaddr : timcr100.ssi.govt.nz != 10.213.130.1
As this box is managing over 2,000 addresses, it is doing a lot of name
resolution and filling up the syslog on the host very quickly. Note that
the management works OK. The customer called HP to get them to resolve the
problem and HP are saying that the DNS configuration of mismatched A and PTR
records is "broken". The engineer has quoted from page 64 of O'Reilly DNS &
BIND:
"To state as a general rule: if a host is multihomed create an address
record for each alias unique to one address. Create a CNAME record for
each alias common to all the addresses"
Of course, this method doesn't provide for a single name per device on the
Spectrum management server.
My questions:
1. Is the described method considered to be a broken implementation? I
haven't seen any explicit statements in the RFC's that state that the PTR
MUST match the A record.
2. Any suggestions on how to work around this other than force a change
with HP?
TIA
J.
James Hall-Kenney
Sytec Resources Limited
More information about the bind-users
mailing list